Join the discussion
Write your take first — we'll ask for email only when you're ready to publish.
- Hacker News
- The XKCD for this exact scenario is 14 years old.by Zhyl
- Some reason that strip doesn't load for me.by doublerabbit
- Kind of a stretch, these days can't imagine anyone that views instagram as a place to store their cherished photos also.by fullshark
- Yeah, and then the charging businesses start selling your stuff anyway. So really, it's the comic creator, who is naive.by jijijijij
- As if Meta glasses weren't creepy enough already.by red_admiral
- Why? Because they can, and they will.
Leaving these services looks difficult or impossible, until you do it, and the world just keeps spinning.
by jmorenoamor - Sometimes it seems like Black Mirror screenwriters work at Meta as a side hustle.by VortexLain
- Comment on that thread:
> This seems entirely counter-productive and creepy.
Apt description of Instagram in general.
by tantalor - by microgpt
- "Damn, this is creepy level though & generally I’m all for ads knowing everything about me. Putting my wife’s profile pic in an ad is too much"
Presumably this reply is a joke?
by bcraven - I feel like having an account on a Meta site is today’s equivalent of being a smoker.by encomiast
- After years off of it I got back on it because living in NYC it’s a lot easier to find and get invited to events in the arts if you’re on it. I wish it weren’t so. I hate every part of it that isn’t a utility.by anon_shill
- Being a smoker in the 1950s maybe.by breezybottom
- There isn't better analogy. I hope it spreads and we will see the same effect and social pressure as smokers faced.by nicce
- This shouldn't really be surprising. It's very similar to what they did ~1.5 year ago when they started to use users' photos to promote Meta AIby penr0se
- Just stop using that cursed websiteby remywang
- Even if you don't use FB, pictures of you tagged by your friends are fair game.by rchaud
- Yeah just done that. Hosed my Instagram account.by cryo32
- It really is that simple. “Users of company with a long track record of unethical behavior surprised at the company’s latest unethical business decision.”
I know it’s not easy for some to stop using their platform for some reason or another. That’s the point. When you use their product not because they are the best choice in a free market with options, but when you use it because you have to. Just don’t surprised when FB keeps pushing the limits.
by fourside - Is Meta abusing its users a problem? Yes. Does the TOS allow for it? Yes. Can people decide to just create a shell account and not actually participate? Sure.
One of the real insidious problems with Instagram and to some extent Facebook is that they provide a free, low friction way for business to communicate with current or potential customers. As a result many small businesses use Instagram as replacement for a public facing website and perhaps a blog or email newsletter. Many small business in my region depend on Instagram for this purpose, its nearly universal. It helps keep you stuck in Instagram so that you can see a business' hours, menu, or special events. I guess a shell account is the answer but you're still going to have to navigate the skinner box feed.
by srmatto - We need a Nitter for Instagram.by microgpt
- You can't create shell account on fb/meta anymore. They will ask to turn on camera and rotate your head.by cute_boi
- If the only way to interact with a business is via Facebook or Instagram, I don't interact with the business.
Unfortunately this is more of a problem for me than it is for them. I hope my position on this becomes more popular over time so that everyone can stop using spy- and adware.
by plagiarist - Every time I try to create a shell account, it gets banned with no reason given. Even if it's just to follow a few influencer accounts.by haliskerbas
- Many years ago (back when Facebook still had sidebar ads), my sister was presented with a dating ad for "Hot Christian Singles" accompanied by a photo of our brother.
It was hilarious, but also mind-boggling. In what scenario would pulling in a friend's profile photo create a useful ad?
- Roll tide.by PyWoody
- I could see people clicking through to see if their friend had a dating profile, if not for the romantic interest the gossip interest.
- > In what scenario would pulling in a friend's profile photo create a useful ad?
Exactly in the scenario you just described. You still remember it and you are actively talking about it years after the fact.
by dewey - Didn't Facebook do this years and years ago?
Yes, 2013: https://mashable.com/archive/facebook-ads-photo#ggcKnNfAUaqy
> According to Facebook's Statement of Rights and Responsibilities:
> You give us permission to use your name, profile picture, content, and information in connection with commercial, sponsored, or related content (such as a brand you like) served or enhanced by us. This means, for example, that you permit a business or other entity to pay us to display your name and/or profile picture with your content or information, without any compensation to you. If you have selected a specific audience for your content or information, we will respect your choice when we use it.
So it's not new. If you don't want this, delete your facebook account: https://www.facebook.com/privacy/dialog/delete-your-informat...
by Cthulhu_ - I wonder if terms and conditions vary between jurisdictions. I would guess so.