Giving a domain a hill to climb: benchmarking as data activation

Join the discussion

• Hacker News
• interesting take not sure I 100% agree

  and yet, Interesting take

  by 2key
• curious where the disagreement lands: the claim i'm least sure of myself is that measurement alone already counts as activation (nothing in the weights changes, so it's a looser sense of the word than usual) the part i'd defend harder is the eval -> reward one: once a benchmark becomes the thing you train against, its flaws stop being measurement error and start being incentives. if you're pushing back somewhere in there, i'd genuinely like to hear it
  by galsapir
• What's with the lack of capitalization?
  by zarzavat
• It is a new brand of a “cool” FAD.
  by nnevatie
• The flaw becomes an incentive...Goood point
  by kjeiwoo
• I wanted to like this and appreciated the genAI tokens were teased into a less AI-ish vernacular, but surfaces and honest caveats drifted back too far to overcome the "I'm human" signaling attempted through lowercase sentences and em dashes replaced with colons.

  I agree with the problem described within, and in the dead comment here.

  by Terretta
• thanks for reading it properly and engaging with the argument!

  writing is hard, expressing ideas cleanly is harder! working on it.

  by galsapir