Birbla

Discussion summary

Dolosse are South African wave-breaking structures used globally, with some debate about their effectiveness and differences from other forms like Tetrapods. The article linked is considered uninformative by some users.

What the discussion says

  • Some users question the effectiveness of coastal armoring like Dolosse.
  • Others highlight the global use of Dolosse and their specific suitability for high-energy coastlines.
  • There is mention of alternative methods like sand replenishment being more effective.
“Dolos are used worldwide, especially in high-energy coastlines.”
— sgt
“Coastal armoring often does not prevent erosion, sand replenishment is preferred.”
— bix6

Join the discussion

Write your take first — we'll ask for email only when you're ready to publish.

Sign in
  • Hacker News
  • These are cool shaped but they don’t actually work; coastal armoring in general does not work as it does not prevent erosion. Sand replenishment is increasingly the path taken. Australia has an amazing pumping system (a jetty blocked longshore sand transport so they pump it around to the other side).

    We could just stop building so close to shore…

    by bix6
  • Not sure why Dolosse are so special?

    There's lots of different forms and shapes of wave breakers, like the Tetrapods [1] that you can find over here across pretty much every coast in Europe.

    Maybe I'm just not getting it why the Dolosse shape is superior?

    [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrapod_(structure)

    by cookiengineer
  • Save yourself the blogspam, go directly to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave-dissipating_concrete_bloc... and enjoy the whole collection !
    by liotier
  • In Germany (on the island Sylt) they recently removed all of these structures again after decades of them being a staple on Sylt's beaches. They were found to have no positive effect on protecting their shores.

    I'm having a hard time to find a good source to quote but look for: "sylt tetrapoden" if you want to dive deeper.

    by walski
  • Interesting. Been to South Africa a bunch but never clocked that they were different from the more common antecedent, the tetrapod[1].

    1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrapod_(structure)

    by duggan
  • Interestingly the author shows a photo of a spot in Cape Town where there are two distinct structures in use - close up, in the photo, are actually Tetrapods - as pointed out in other comments, these are an earlier invention from France and also used quite extensively throughout many parts of the world (including... right here where the Dolosse were invented).

    Further down that jetty are structures with the actual Dolos geometry. It would be interesting to know if, specifically, those geometries were chosen specifically to be placed in those two parts of the wall as they are for specific properties, or if came down to having certain quantities made on hand and their distributions matched the shape of the wall required, or what.

    You can see what I mean, this distinction in the exact location where that photo is taken on google maps, here:

    https://maps.app.goo.gl/Vn3tGhM81oMqPVpm9

    -33.899126, 18.412751 Mouille Point, Cape Town, 8005, South Africa

    by mk_stjames
  • Finnally something I have knowledge of. Dolosse were invent in South Africa many years ago, but they are only one type of concrete block for wave dissipation and protection. Many others exist and some of them are patented and require the payment of royalties to be used. Anyway, in Portugal we do not use dolosse ever. We used it once in Sines deepwater breakwater, which suffered a catastrophic collapse in 1979. The promise of dolosse is that the blocks work together because of their shape and thus the individual block can be lighter and cheaper. This does not work in practice, at least in high energy seas. The ocean is unforgiven. What happens is that if only a few blocks break the whole structure will quickly collapse during a storm. And things can break due to a series of problems and risks. Concrete is only good at resist compression stresses and reinforcement with rebar is almost always a bad idea in ocean conditions, so complex shapes are hard to make and to move without introducing unwanted stresses that reduce the design strength conditions. Other types of blocks rely mostly on their design weight and density, and the shape is just used for increasing energy dissipation and overtopping. For example, tetrapods can be moved with only compression forces on the block.
    by nusq

Explore Birbla archives