Comments

Hacker News

Curious why would someone prefer HFS+ over APFS?

by nerdsniper

I have a big external spinning HDD. Someone suggested creating an encrypted APFS partition, and put a single big file inside (mount it as unencrypted HFS+ image). Would this work? And would I still suffer from APFS's horrible HDD performance?

by lifeteam715

I wonder why they're removing support for encryption when clearly they have the code for it and still supporting the actual FS

by edude03

Join the discussion

Write your take first — we'll ask for email only when you're ready to publish.

  • Hacker News
  • Curious why would someone prefer HFS+ over APFS?
  • I have a big external spinning HDD. Someone suggested creating an encrypted APFS partition, and put a single big file inside (mount it as unencrypted HFS+ image). Would this work? And would I still suffer from APFS's horrible HDD performance?
  • I wonder why they're removing support for encryption when clearly they have the code for it and still supporting the actual FS
macOS 28 will not support encrypted HFS+ volumes · Birbla