Birbla

Join the discussion

Write your take first — we'll ask for email only when you're ready to publish.

Sign in
  • Hacker News
  • Blocked because I don't use cookies. Ok, I've always preferred mpv anyway.
    by ekjhgkejhgk
  • Why do you do this to yourself?
    by xena
  • I've 3rd party cookies blocked and it works just fine. Have you disabled all cookies?!
    by nisiddharth
  • I wish Unity's built-in videoplayer wasn't such a disappointment. The performance on Windows is god awful. Have had to write a mass video reference recompressor/in-scene replacer that just attempts to pick the best compression flags and reduces resolution just avoid dropping frames playing ~1080p videos on multi-core PC's with discrete GPU's. Mac was fine playing even the overly high res original footage, high 2000+ pixel portrait tutorial videos.

    Wrote a proper double-buffering video/audio player in Unity using parts of an ffmpeg wrapper over ten years ago. Seems silly they never did anything similar officially, just used lackluster platform API's.

    by maxlin
  • Completely agree! Unfortunately this is the Unity MO.

    A tool that's a bit half baked.

    They have been doing a hell of a lot better lately though.

    by thsbrown
  • Sidenote:

    Video game programming with unity was an absolute nightmare to try and get working with any kind of gitops and or with multiple people working on the same code base a couple of years ago

    Wonder if that changed ?

    by happyPersonR
  • They acquired Plastic SCM around 2020 and I believe they integrated it into the engine, but that was shortly after I stopped using Unity
    by 1bpp
  • Unity native files are still pretty much a nightmare to merge. With that said I find it's not too hard to break things up in a way that multiple people can work on separate pieces of the game so the actual files don't need to be merged.

    While plasticSCM has come a long way, I still find it a bit buggy and hard to work around. I miss the more advanced features of git.

    by thsbrown
  • I don't know why, but on windows, the first time I start VLC after a windows boot, it takes about 5s to 8s to open a video file, any sort of video file

    I suspect it's a graphics driver issue, or something else

    by jokoon
  • It's caused by a stale plugin cache, which somehow triggers a blocking windows defender scan on application launch.

    I only managed to figure that out thanks to this[1] reddit comment, which also includes a solution:

      Noticed this a while back with 3.0.23. Managed to troubleshoot via debug logs.
  
  Basically the plugin cache goes stale and has to rebuild itself every first launch. No clue why.
  
  To fix: go to C:\Program Files\VideoLAN\VLC (or wherever you installed) with a terminal in administrator mode.
  run the command: ./vlc-cache-gen.exe "C:\Program Files\VideoLAN\VLC\plugins"
  
  That will rebuild the plugins.dat file which should fix it.
    No windows defender exclusion required.

    [1]: https://old.reddit.com/r/VLC/comments/1skofwx/vlc_3023_windo...

    by krono
  • Forgive me for my ignorance - but my understanding is that VLC is a frontend for ffmpeg, and even ffmpeg is 'just' a wrapper for hardware video decoders such as NVDEC when viewing supported codecs, like h264/5.
    by torginus
  • My understanding is that VLC and FFMpeg are both projects which develop in house codecs and also incorporate codecs developed by third parties.
    by mastax
  • Just in case you only read the headline and were confused, this is libVLC which underpins the VLC player.
    by bananaboy
  • VRChat folks will love this. Videoplayers are embedded into Unity scenes aka "maps" as a regular imported lib. The videoplayer is a drawn surface where users can see video playback. Most commonly used for streaming live music from a stream like Twitch.
    by hparadiz
  • Can a unity dev/game dev help elucidate why you'd use vlc in unity?

    For cutscene playback?

    by fusslo
  • Unity video player leaves a lot to be desired.

    The standout option for a more elaborate video handling was typically AVPro. It's a really good option, with that said with vlc stepping up hopefully it's no longer strictly necessary.

    by thsbrown
  • RTSP support, twitch-style in-game visio, any kind of non-game Unity apps (there are many), 360 video playback, mediaplayer in VR headset, simulators of all kinds, etc..
    by martz
  • Unity includes its own video player implementation ( https://docs.unity3d.com/Manual/Video.html ), so presumably you'd mainly want to use VLC for wider range of supported codecs?
    by csande17
  • For a sandbox game this is very useful, where you can spawn video players in-game. For social games (like VRChat) this is also great since synced video playback is a very popular feature for people to watch content together in VR.
    by harrisoned
  • To everybody else being confused: This is about Unity the game engine, not Unity the desktop environment.
    by Hendrikto
  • Unity (the DE) was discontinued 9 years ago..
    by tokai
  • Recently added support for Linux to VLC for Unity, with full hardware decoding.

    It uses OpenGL rendering through GLX and EGL, with DMA-BUF texture sharing to pass video frames efficiently to Unity’s renderer.

    Only x86_64 is supported at this time. In the future, I will add ARM64 support as well as Vulkan.

    by martz
  • Thank you very much.
    by SurajMishra
  • Would it not be more efficient to create the decoder in-process, then you could feed it the bitstream via a compute buffer, and the video would be rendered to a texture.
    by torginus
  • Don't forget to build 'correct' ELF64 binaries for broad elf(glibc)/linux distro support (-static-libgcc -static-libstdc++, and tight glibc ABI version control with binutils VERSION scripts).

    At least those build options should be default.

    by sylware
  • On a similar note: Godot VLC (<https://github.com/xiSage/godot-vlc>), because let's not pretend we don't remember the Unity terms change controversy.
    by tmtvl
  • yes this is good too, actually started contributing to this :)
    by martz
  • Context about the Unity terms change controversy: https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/unity-is-killing-its-...

    > Initially, the Runtime Fee sought to charge developers a per install tariff once projects had passed certain milestones. It was a decision that left many users reeling, resulting in a colossal backlash (…)

    How users reacted: https://old.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/16h9lnw/whats...

    > Any install, any reinstall, any installation on a second device, each and every one slap the dev with a fee. It gets dumber, because that cracked copy of your game on the high seas still incurs a fee when the pirate installs it. You might think we're at peak stupidity. You might think anyone who makes anything with Unity is a "fucking idiot" (the CEO certainly does), but we're not done yet. It's retroactive. (…)

    by thih9