Discussion summary
Mcpsnoop is a Wireshark-like tool for MCP that provides live visualization and transparency. Users discuss potential redaction of sensitive data and integration options.
What the discussion says
- Some users suggest redacting secrets like keys before logging.
- The tool captures JSON-RPC messages but not headers, limiting redaction.
- There are existing MCPs for Wireshark that can be used as alternatives.
- Adding a web interface for browsing data is considered feasible.
“Payload secrets are probably the scarier part.”
“The gap of visualization of calling the AI client is covered by your product!!”
Comments
Hacker News
by geraldsterling
by yr_animesh
by kerlenton
by mmakeev
by kerlenton
by atmanactive
by InfraScaler
by kerlenton
Is it possible to add a simple browser page to brows the data in a simple way?. Thank you.
by chopete3
by kerlenton
by tiku
by iamgopal
by cidd
by kerlenton
by geraldsterling
by rstagi
by kerlenton
There are many AI auditability proxies;
awesome-auditable-ai: "A curated list of papers, tools, datasets, benchmarks, and standards for building, evaluating, and auditing reliable AI agents" https://github.com/yzhao062/awesome-auditable-ai
Aegis and LiteLLM, for example, are pre-execution firewalls that add a cryptographic audit trail. https://github.com/Justin0504/aegis
by westurner
Join the discussion
Write your take first — we'll ask for email only when you're ready to publish.
- Hacker News
- Makes sense. Payload secrets are probably the scarier part anyway. Would a simple redact config make sense, like keys/patterns to scrub before writing traces?by geraldsterling
- Its really a great tool. The gap of visualization of calling the AI client is covered by your product!!by yr_animesh
- Thanks a lot!by kerlenton
- One question about http mode, you carry authorization headers. Do you redact bearer tokens before captures hit the logs?by mmakeev
- There's nothing redacted because the header isn't collected in the first place. Under http mode, the proxy intercepts the JSON-RPC messages, but not their headers, so there's no way for the log to contain the Authorization header and the bearer passes through unlogged. The contents of the messages themselves aren't redacted, which means if the secret is in the payload, it'll end up in the trace. The trace stays on your machine, and if you don't want anything to go to the disk at all, use --no-trace.by kerlenton
- This is awesome, thank you. What's missing now is an MCP for Wireshark.by atmanactive
- You can just get your agent to run tshark :)by InfraScaler
- Thanks! Actually, there is already an MCP for Wireshark, for example https://github.com/0xKoda/WireMCPby kerlenton
- This is awesome. Your comparison make it easy. This approach makes perfect sense to give 100% visibility into the back and forth.
Is it possible to add a simple browser page to brows the data in a simple way?. Thank you.
by chopete3 - Thank you! Showing the data in a web page should definitely be possible. But I’m not sure if this matches the original idea I had, where the tool would run in the terminal only. Why do you feel the need to show the data in a web page? Is there anything missing in the CLI?by kerlenton
- To be fair, it is really simple to build your own proxy. I built a custom authentication layer with logging and limits for Dify MCP with just 2 prompts in Kimi. Later built it out with database limts etc.by tiku
- Great. I dream to see MCP of MCP, discovery, installation, security and usage should be automatic.by iamgopal
- I feel most of the comments here are from botsby cidd
- Maybe, but I didn't do it. Perhaps people are boosting their karma?by kerlenton
- It's getting bad. Definitely a hole that needs to be filled...by geraldsterling
- "MCP Inspector [...] never sees the traffic between your client and your server." This line resonates a lot, what you're building makes sense to me! I had built something similar to track these interactions and turn them into a benchmark, I'm gonna try this out.by rstagi
- Thanks, that means a lot. Would love to hear how it goes once you try itby kerlenton
- Remote debugging and post-mortem debugging support might be useful.
There are many AI auditability proxies;
awesome-auditable-ai: "A curated list of papers, tools, datasets, benchmarks, and standards for building, evaluating, and auditing reliable AI agents" https://github.com/yzhao062/awesome-auditable-ai
Aegis and LiteLLM, for example, are pre-execution firewalls that add a cryptographic audit trail. https://github.com/Justin0504/aegis
by westurner
Related stories
Jim's TrueType QR Code Font
github.com · 177 points · 22 comments
Rowboat – Open-source, local-first alternative to Claude Desktop
github.com · 158 points · 45 comments
MacSurf 1.68 – NetSurf on OS 9 Released
github.com · 76 points · 18 comments
Docx-CLI: agents read/edit Word docs using 1/2 the time and tokens
github.com · 64 points · 26 comments
GitHub Freno: cooperative, highly available throttler service
github.com · 40 points · 1 comments
Pure-Python symbolic regression that rediscovered Kepler's law from 8 data point
github.com · 38 points · 12 comments